Need More Information On The Rent to Own Process?

Don't Wait. Get Started with Right Now!

Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

All  »  New York  »  Shelter Island, NY   443 Listings Found

Relax in old world style in this recently remodeled Farmhouse with fenced in pool. There are 3 beds, 1.5 bathrooms, sheltered porch...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Located on tranquil Menantic Creek. This beautiful new home has 4 beds, three bathrooms, living room with beach stone fireplace and...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Shelter Island Heights home with three beds and 3 bathrooms, heated pool, tennis. Close to Crescent Beach, Sunset Beach and Heights...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

The four plus bedroom, 4 bathrooms Colonial sits atop a breezy hill with full sun heated pool, granite kitchen, dining area. spacious...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Beautiful Victorian swimming-pool home in Historic Shelter Island Heights. This home features 5 beds, sleeping up to ten people with 2...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This stylish home offers 4 beds, three bathrooms, living room and dedicated dining area area, cook's kitchen with access to expansive...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Across from community association beach sits this lovely 4 beds, two bathrooms ranch home. Living room, eat-in-kitchen, mudroom, pool....

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This 4 beds cottage accessible to beach, restaurants and tennis. Take pleasure in Shelter Island's tranquil Island life. Water views...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This wonderful vacation home, nestled on 1.10 acres in Hay Beach, Shelter Island, offers 4 beds, and 2 bathrooms. Open floor plan,...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Summer time in Westmoreland Farm. This cozy cottage offers 3 bedrooms two bathrooms with kitchen, dedicated dining area room, living...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This inviting home with 3 beds and 2 bathrooms is tucked away in a quiet and quiet location. Master en-suite, living room with...

$14,000 Weekly
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Impeccably presented this waterfront home makes the most of it's harbor side location, on Coecles Harbor. Sited on 2.20 acres this...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This 3 beds, two bathrooms home, has 1500+ sq. ft. of immaculate beach-chic contemporary furnishings. It has a large yard and deck...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

WebID 63767This incredible property on Shelter Island sits on a serene and private park like estate of 3.6 acres. Comprised of an...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

The rental offering is brand new construction, with 589' of waterfront on the peninsula of Menanatic Creek! Water views are from most...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Do You Qualify for a Rent to Own Home Program?

Don't Wait. Get Started with Right Now! is the #1 provider of Shelter Island, New York houses for rent listings.

Our goal is to offer the highest quality results, along with helpful Shelter Island resources and support. We understand that finding genuine houses for rent in Shelter Island can be very difficult. Even more challenging is trying to search Shelter Island, NY listings for free.

After discovering how difficult it was for Shelter Island buyers and sellers searching online, has become dedicated to providing users with the most current, accurate, and detailed listings in Shelter Island, New York.

If you have any questions or suggestions for improving our site, please contact us here.

Trouble Finding Local Houses for Rent Listings?

If the initial results in Shelter Island, New York did not provide any listings of interest, or you just want more selections, click any of the blue tabs just above the search results for more.

Thanks for visiting and good luck!