Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

All  »  New York  »  Shelter Island, NY   386 Listings Found

Charming cape, newly redecorated with lots of sunlight, formal entry open’s to great room area and fireplace, eat-in-kitchen, premium...

$12,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This 4 bedrooms/ 2.5 bathrooms Traditional has an open kitchen that leads to the dining/ living space with soaring ceiling with...

$25,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

The rental offering is brand new construction, with 589' of waterfront on the peninsula of Menanatic Creek! Water views are from most...

$80,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

SHELTER ISLAND HEIGHTS-OFF SEASON WATERFRONT Enjoy 180 degree waterfront views of boats, ferries, and the North Fork from the...

$2,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

And views of the water from almost every room in the house. A waterside patio with fireplace, dining table and lounge chairs. Chef's...

$12,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Swimming or just strolling and holding hands. A three BEDROOMs, two BATHROOMs, Living Room with fireplace, Dedicated dining area room,...

$18,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

SHELTER ISLAND-BEACH AND VIEWS A Mid-Century Ranch with incredible water views, so close you practically feel the salt spray. A...

$15,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

SHELTER ISLAND-Sweet cottage with one BEDROOMs and one BATHROOMs. Large living room, Kitchen, screened in porch and washer dryer....

$13,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Cozy beach house in desirable Silver Beach. Just a quick walk to beautiful Shell Beach. 3 beds, two bathrooms and a pool with a deck...

$15,000
49 Brander Parkway, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This perfect cottage is located in the Hilo Shores section of Shelter Island. Has been re-done, and sleeps six. It is convenient to...

$10,000
9 Hilo Dr, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

New Deck Overlooking West Neck Creek -Bright & Airy Vacation Home On Private. Newly Decorated With central air conditioned, Pool/Game...

$5,500
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Beautiful Waterfront Home On West Neck Creek On Shelter Island. New Deck Overlooking West Neck Creek -Bright & Airy Vacation Home On...

$5,500
8 Gazon Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

SHELTER ISLAND-Perfect summer retreat. This light and bright Contemporary waterfront home with sandy beach offers a private master...

$25,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

SHELTER ISLAND-Nestled behind the main house is a two BEDROOMs plus sleeping loft, one BATHROOMs accessory cottage with pond views....

$20,000
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

SHELTER ISLAND-New to market and ready to rent. Set up as the perfect beach house with water views from every room. Filled with light...

$14,000 Weekly
Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

RentUntilYouOwn.com is the #1 provider of Shelter Island, New York houses for rent listings.

Our goal is to offer the highest quality results, along with helpful Shelter Island resources and support. We understand that finding genuine houses for rent in Shelter Island can be very difficult. Even more challenging is trying to search Shelter Island, NY listings for free.

After discovering how difficult it was for Shelter Island buyers and sellers searching online, RentUntilYouOwn.com has become dedicated to providing users with the most current, accurate, and detailed listings in Shelter Island, New York.

If you have any questions or suggestions for improving our site, please contact us here.

Trouble Finding Local Houses for Rent Listings?

If the initial results in Shelter Island, New York did not provide any listings of interest, or you just want more selections, click any of the blue tabs just above the search results for more.

Thanks for visiting and good luck!