Do You Qualify for a Rent to Own Home Program?

Don't Wait. Get Started with Right Now!

Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

All  »  New York  »  Shelter Island, NY   5846 Listings Found

Cozy cottage with living room, dedicated dining area room, kitchen, bedroom, bath with shower and screen porch.

53 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This newly remodeled contemporary with 170' of bullheaded waterfront with expansive water views of Gardiner's Bay and Mashomack. With...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Upper Heights location. Country feel. Convenient to public golf course and just up the road from Sunset Beach Restaurant, Crescent...

48 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Nestled next to preserved lands, this comfortable and spacious home offers the best of Shelter Island living with spectacular sunsets...

54 Manhanset Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Chic, white, bright 3 bedrrom, 2 baths ranch style.

73 N Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This beautiful Contemporary home has 1.8 acres of rolling green lawn and water views of both Coecles Harbor and Gardiner's Bay. The...

4 Sheep Pasture Ln, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This Summer Cottage Is Simply And Elegantly Decorated. It Is Perfect For Peaceful Weekends In The Country. Spacious and Private...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

dramatic high ceilings, CAC, heated pool, outdoor shower, wireless, broadband & internet service, DirecTV, three TIVO units & LCD...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This Splendid Waterfront home located in desirable Silver Beach is the perfect Summer Rental. Waterside deck and sunroom, open floor...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Spacious 5 beds, three bathrooms home in the Menantic area of Shelter Island. This stylishly updated home boasts an open plan with...

4 Gazon Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Additional rental periods available: MD-LD $60,000; June $12,000; July $22,000; August-LD $27,000;; Additional rental periods...

8 Bay Shore Dr, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

4 beds, two baths, kitchen with eating area, a-c, fireplace, living room, .75 acre yard.Near-by to Crescent Beach, Tuck Shop,...

74 N Menantic Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Sail into Summer from our Southern waters. Relax in whimsy and delight in this charming country cottage in its own meadow, with...

5 Cove Way, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

This secluded 3 beds, 2 baths Silver Beach house is perfect for any season. Enjoy the pool, covered front porch and near-by beaches in...

Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Pristine and sunny contemporary with views over creek out to North Haven. House has four beds, 2 baths, dock, association tennis and...

7 Osprey Ln, Shelter Island, NY, 11964Details »

Do You Qualify for a Rent to Own Home Program?

Don't Wait. Get Started with Right Now! is the #1 provider of Shelter Island, New York houses for rent listings.

Our goal is to offer the highest quality results, along with helpful Shelter Island resources and support. We understand that finding genuine houses for rent in Shelter Island can be very difficult. Even more challenging is trying to search Shelter Island, NY listings for free.

After discovering how difficult it was for Shelter Island buyers and sellers searching online, has become dedicated to providing users with the most current, accurate, and detailed listings in Shelter Island, New York.

If you have any questions or suggestions for improving our site, please contact us here.

Trouble Finding Local Houses for Rent Listings?

If the initial results in Shelter Island, New York did not provide any listings of interest, or you just want more selections, click any of the blue tabs just above the search results for more.

Thanks for visiting and good luck!