Houses for Rent in Shelter Island, NY

All  »  New York  »  Shelter Island, NY   953 Listings Found

The ultimate in Greenport living! Just a short distance from historic Greenport's shops, restaurants, and waterfront. Take in stunning...

$4,500
42 Stirling Cove, Greenport, NY, 11944Details »

So Very Close to a Beautiful Bay Beach! 3 Bedrooms/2 Baths. Central Air Conditioning. 2 Large Decks. Nice Yard! Summer 2023 - MD-LD...

$28,000
1075 Inlet Lane, Greenport, NY, 11944Details »

Beautifully updated Greenport Village home for rent on 1st Street. This home offers comfort with quality interior finishes and detail....

$3,800
630 1st Street, Greenport, NY, 11944Details »

This fully renovated Greenport home has been stylishly decorated and features a large, eat-in kitchen, expansive living room, 3...

$15,000
905 9th Street, Greenport, NY, 11944Details »

Wonderful North Fork summer rental with in ground pool located on a quiet block with a private community sandy beach at the end of...

$17,000
1750 Gillette Dr, East Marion, NYDetails »

Imagine waking up to breathtaking sunrises over the bay and the sound of gentle waves lapping at your doorstep. This Bay front cottage...

$80,000
2395 Bay Ave, East Marion, NYDetails »

Experience the ultimate North Fork summer with the perfect combination of comfort and privacy in this spacious 4 bedroom home with...

$12,000
2905 Private Rd, East Marion, NYDetails »

Unwind on Marion Lake and recharge on the Bay! This 2-bedroom, 1 bathroom lakefront cottage is the perfect escape! Just steps away...

$60,000
2085 Bay Ave, East Marion, NYDetails »

Live the waterfront dream! Imagine having the choice to wake up overlooking Gardiner's Bay or tranquil Marion Lake. This immaculate 3...

$75,000
295 Rabbit Ln, East Marion, NYDetails »

Charming and chic 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath Cottage on Lake Marion with many charming original features. Open, sunny floor plan with common...

$16,000
1500 Trumans Path, East Marion, NYDetails »

House is at the end of Ketcham Lane. Introducing a Sequestered Post Modern custom designed home. The property backs up to Cove Beach...

$30,000
11003 Main Rd, East Marion, NYDetails »

Endless Summer! Why Limit Your Summertime Fun to a Few Months? Enjoy This Resort Feel Luxurious New Construction Modern Home with...

$9,000
2080 Stars Rd, East Marion, NYDetails »

Escape to your perfect summer retreat at 3 Linda Lane in Sag Harbor! Recently renovated to perfection, this gem features 4 bedrooms, 2...

$50,000
3 Linda Ln, Sag Harbor, NYDetails »

In The Heart Of Downtown Southold, Close To Everything Including Einstein Square, Southold General, Maroni's, Food Market, and All...

$3,500
54100 Route 25, Southold, NYDetails »

Treasure the memories made during the Summer of '24 at this chic waterview home overlooking Corey Creek. Completely redesigned and...

$4,800
780 Minnehaha Blvd, Southold, NYDetails »

RentUntilYouOwn.com is the #1 provider of Shelter Island, New York houses for rent listings.

Our goal is to offer the highest quality results, along with helpful Shelter Island resources and support. We understand that finding genuine houses for rent in Shelter Island can be very difficult. Even more challenging is trying to search Shelter Island, NY listings for free.

After discovering how difficult it was for Shelter Island buyers and sellers searching online, RentUntilYouOwn.com has become dedicated to providing users with the most current, accurate, and detailed listings in Shelter Island, New York.

If you have any questions or suggestions for improving our site, please contact us here.

Trouble Finding Local Houses for Rent Listings?

If the initial results in Shelter Island, New York did not provide any listings of interest, or you just want more selections, click any of the blue tabs just above the search results for more.

Thanks for visiting and good luck!